MATTIE LEE SIMPSON AND HOWARD SIMPSON, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS,
v.
KNUT KNUTSEN, O.A.S., DEFENDANT-APPELLEE; MATTIE LEE SIMPSON AND HOWARD SIMPSON, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES, V. KNUT KNUTSEN, O.A.S., DEFENDANT-APPELLANT

9th Cir. | 1971-06-23
Nos. 24299, 24301
444 F.2d 523 United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (1971) Negative Treatment
Cited by 26 cases

AI-generated. These summaries, headnotes, and key points are machine-generated and may contain errors or omissions. Always verify against the full opinion text below. Not legal advice.


Holding

The court held that under general maritime law, damages for loss of consortium were not recoverable, and affirmed the application of comparative negligence. The court remanded the issue of income tax deduction for reconsideration.


Facts & Procedural History

Appellants, the widow and son of a deceased longshoreman, brought a wrongful death action. The trial court found the vessel unseaworthy and the longsh…

The full statement of facts, procedural history, and disposition for this case are member content.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

© FLexlaw, Inc. — AI-generated enrichments are proprietary. All rights reserved.


Opinion of the Court
PER CURIAM:

PER CURIAM:

Appellants, the widow and son of a longshoreman, brought this wrongful death action on the bases of diversity of citizenship, the California Wrongful Death Act (California Code of Civil Procedure Sec. 377), and the general maritime law of the United States. The District Court, jury-waived, found that the vessel moored in San Francisco Bay on which the longshoreman was working when he met accidental death, was un-seaworthy; that the unseaworthiness was a proximate cause of the accident; that there was negligence on the decedent’s part contributing to the accident; that applying the rule of comparative negligence, the damages awarded should be reduced by fifty percent; that the damages awarded to the widow should include nothing for loss of consortium; that income taxes on the decedent’s earnings should not be considered in computing damages; and that the adult son’s claim for loss of support, affection and companionship was without merit. Judgment was entered accordingly.

Appellants contend that the District Court erred in refusing to award damages for loss of care, comfort and society of decedent (consortium), and in finding the decedent guilty of contributory negligence and applying the doctrine of comparative negligence. Appel-lee cross-appealed contending that the District Court erred in refusing to deduct income taxes in computing loss of the decedent’s earnings.

The parties and the District Court had been laboring under the doctrine of The Harrisburg, 119 U.S. 199, 7 S.Ct. 140, 30 L.Ed. 358 (1886), that no action lay under general maritime law to recover for wrongful death absent a statutory right thereto, which doctrine had been judicially modified to permit such action under a state wrongful death statute when the death resulted from a maritime tort committed within the territorial waters of that state. Western Fuel Co. v. Garcia, 257 U.S. 233, 242, 42 S.Ct. 89, 90, 66 L.Ed. 210 (1921).

However, after the appeal and cross-appeal were filed herein, and the briefs submitted by the parties, the Supreme Court held in Moragne v. State Marine Lines, Inc., 398 U.S. 375, 90 S.Ct. 1772, 26 L.Ed.2d 339 (1970), that an action for wrongful death does lie under general maritime law for violation of maritime duties, expressly overruling The Harrisburg.

We find that under general maritime law the District Court did not err in refusing to award damages for loss of consortium,1 and in finding contributory negligence and applying the doctrine of comparative negligence.2 We, therefore, affirm the judgment as to appellants.

As to appellee’s cross-appeal, we remand the matter to the District Court for reconsideration of the issue of deduction of income taxes in computing loss of the decedent’s earnings in the light of Momgne.

Affirmed in part; remanded in part.

. Igneri v. Cie. de Transports Oceaniques, 323 F. 2d 257 (2d Cir. 1963) cert. den. 376 U.S. 949, 84 S.Ct. 965, 11 L.Ed.2d 969; Petition of United States Steel Corporation, 436 F. 2d 1256 (6 Cir. 1970).

. Hornsby v. Fish Meal Co., 431 F. 2d 865 (5 Cir. 1970).


Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus


Citator

Cited By (12 total)

Previewing 3 of 12 citing cases — full citator treatment, depth of discussion, and citing context are member features.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

Authorities Cited

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw