FERMIN TORRES, PETITIONER,
v.
THE STATE OF FLORIDA, RESPONDENT

Fla. 3d DCA | 2004-06-30
No. 3D03-3336
Before SCHWARTZ, C.J., and COPE and WELLS, JJ.
879 So. 2d 1254 Florida District Court of Appeal, Third District (2004)

AI-generated. These summaries, headnotes, and key points are machine-generated and may contain errors or omissions. Always verify against the full opinion text below. Not legal advice.

Synopsis

Fermin Torres petitioned for relief based on ineffective assistance of appellate counsel regarding his sentencing. The court found that appellate counsel failed to detect and challenge that Torres's life sentence exceeded the applicable sentencing guidelines, and remanded for resentencing while rejecting his claim regarding scoring errors.


Holding

The court granted relief on the ineffective assistance claim because appellate counsel should have detected that the 1997 guidelines (not the 1998 version) applied and that the life sentence was above guidelines without stated departure reasons. The court rejected Torres's claim that his separate firearm conviction should be vacated, finding that his second degree murder was properly classified as a first degree felony rather than enhanced to a life felony.


Headnotes

[1] A defendant is entitled to relief on a claim of ineffective assistance of appellate counsel when counsel fails to recognize and address an error in the application of sen…

[2] A life sentence imposed for a crime committed on April 17, 1998, must be evaluated under the 1997 version of the sentencing guidelines if the trial occurred after the 199…

Previewing 2 of 5 headnotes on this case. FLexlaw’s editorially structured points of law — every proposition, pinpointed — are reserved for members.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

Key Quotes

“Under those guidelines, "If the total sentence points are equal to or greater than 363, the court may sentence the offender to life imprisonment." Id. § 921.0014(2). Under the scoresheet, the defendant's score was 361.4 points. Thus, the guidelines range for the defendant did not include the life sentence.”

Establishes that Torres's life sentence exceeded the applicable sentencing guidelines range.

Previewing 1 of 3 key quotes on this case — the court’s exact language, pinpointed for members.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

Facts & Procedural History

Torres was convicted of second degree murder with a firearm and unlawful possession of a firearm while committing a felony on April 17, 1998. He was s…

The full statement of facts, procedural history, and disposition for this case are member content.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

© FLexlaw, Inc. — AI-generated enrichments are proprietary. All rights reserved.


Opinion of the Court
PER CURIAM.

PER CURIAM.

Fermin Torres has filed a timely petition in this court alleging ineffective assistance of appellate counsel. See Fla. R.App. P. 9.141(c). The State has properly conceded that the petition has merit. We therefore remand for a new sentencing hearing.

Defendant-petitioner Torres was convicted of second degree murder with a firearm, and unlawful possession of a firearm while committing a felony. The offense date was April 17, 1998. The defendant was sentenced to life in prison on second degree murder, and sentence was suspended on the firearm charge.

The defendant argues that under the applicable sentencing guidelines score-sheet, life imprisonment was above the guidelines for the defendant’s crime, absent a departure. In the defendant’s case, the life sentence was pronounced but no departure reasons were stated.

Based on the defendant’s crime date, the 1997 version of the sentencing guidelines is applicable. Under those guidelines, “If the total sentence points are equal to or greater than 363, the court may sentence the offender to life imprisonment.” Id. § 921.0014(2). Under the scoresheet, the defendant’s score was 361.4 points. Thus, the guidelines range for the defendant did not include the life sentence.

We surmise that by the time the defendant was tried in 2001, the 1998 criminal punishment code had gone into effect. See §§ 921.002-.00265, Fla. Stat. (Supp. 1998). Under that version of the guidelines, the guidelines score provides a sentencing floor, but the court can impose any sentence up to the legal maximum. In this case the court sentenced the defendant to the legal maximum. Apparently the parties and the court assumed that the 1998 version of the guidelines was applicable to the defendant’s case, but it was not. Since this error should have been detected and addressed by the defendant’s appellate counsel, see generally Fla. R.Crím. P. 3.800(b), we conclude that the defendant’s claim is well taken and he is entitled to relief.

We therefore reverse the defendant’s sentencing order and remand for resentencing. Since the trial court was not aware that it was imposing a departure sentence in the defendant’s case, the trial court may consider a departure sentence if there are grounds to do so. See State v. Betancourt, 552 So. 2d 1107 (Fla.1989).

We reject the defendant’s claim of scoring error on the sentencing guidelines scoresheet. The defendant maintains that his conviction for second degree murder was enhanced from a first degree felony punishable by life imprisonment, see § 782.04(2), Fla. Stat. (1997), to a life felony on account of the use of a firearm. See id. § 775.087(l)(a). On that premise, he argues that his separate conviction for possession of a firearm while committing a felony must be vacated. See Cleveland v. State, 587 So. 2d 1145 (Fla.1991); Grene v. State, 702 So. 2d 510, 511 (Fla. 3d DCA 1997) (en banc).

The defendant’s premise, however, is incorrect. Both on the judgment and in the trial court’s oral pronouncement, the offense of second degree murder was classified as a first degree felony punishable by life imprisonment, and was not enhanced to a life felony. Thus a separate conviction for possession of a firearm while committing a felony was permissible.

Petition granted; remanded for a new sentencing hearing.


Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus


Citator

Authorities Cited

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw