ANDRES GONZALEZ
v.
MIAMI DADE COUNTY

11th Cir. Ct. App. Div. | 2022-07-29
No. 2021-000057-AP-01
1 FLCA 7415 Eleventh Judicial Circuit Court, Appellate Division (2022)

AI-generated. These summaries, headnotes, and key points are machine-generated and may contain errors or omissions. Always verify against the full opinion text below. Not legal advice.

Synopsis

Andres Gonzalez appealed a Miami-Dade County decision regarding alleged errors in police procedures and evidence handling. The appellate court reviewed claims concerning procedural violations and the sufficiency of evidence supporting the lower court's findings.

Holding

The court addressed Gonzalez's procedural claims regarding police conduct and evidence management, examining whether proper notice and opportunity to be heard were provided and whether the county's procedures met statutory requirements.

Headnotes

[1] A court may not impose a harsher sentence on a defendant for exercising their right to a jury trial.

[2] A defendant's sentence may not be enhanced based on the court's belief that the defendant lied during their testimony.

Previewing 2 of 6 headnotes on this case. FLexlaw’s editorially structured points of law — every proposition, pinpointed — are reserved for members.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence
Key Quotes

“the Department's procedures did not provide the customer with proper notice and opportunity to be heard regarding the meter registration”

Establishes that procedural due process violations occurred regarding notice requirements

Previewing 1 of 3 key quotes on this case — the court’s exact language, pinpointed for members.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence
Facts & Procedural History

The case involved Gonzalez's challenge to police conduct and evidence collection procedures in Miami-Dade County. The relevant facts centered on claim…

The full statement of facts, procedural history, and disposition for this case are member content.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

© FLexlaw, Inc. — AI-generated enrichments are proprietary. All rights reserved.

Opinion of the Court

                                         ! !"#$  %        &'"#(#   ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))* +,-.-+.  '!#!"#0!1(2134 #5  ! !"#0"$6$! "0$ !"$5$!0$"75!#51$($"055$!#800!9$ !57! 5(65 $5#( :$ '5$ 7#   653# ;!#&<5#($5:$"2' 0"$  ! !"#$  $51(!# ="#>"#?#5# !57! 5( "2# 3  "$#3 5#( #815  =#@57!# &&!& 5# "2# 3 "$#30"$&'"#(#  !57! 5("2# 3  =0"$6 6?5#(   6  !1!#8ABCDC4!1(*4*D  [*2]        !"! #!!!$ % %&'()"! *+!),!' -! % .$!/ !!  % ' !, 0 !  1234555677 +! 06  ! $' $ 8,!$9!9,!$!%6 :;<=>?@ABC . E 9!FG4GG4 !,9!$9HI &'( )#9 F ,  $$9 +&'()"! *+! )HJK LMNOHPQ R/ SSQR S  TUVWN X9%!,9!$4 !,!',F0 Y9%'   ! $ 8$Z9! ,!,!F4$9 [, 0$9 #.\])'!!9' 8$ ,!8 ^$9 +!, 6_!' _0!9!FG`a4!9%&FGG4"X*)',!'! / !,!F^'09+9 00$9,!,!F + $0F$[%4$$9,0FZ9!4 0$9!+%   ,!'6]  b8'0! GG4 ! !8 +!  ,  !'8 Z9!6] )$'0!GG4"X*)+ F0$$!,!F  0 '!! %4!9 % %0!+!9%6 ] E 9!FG`4"X*)'0 !!1234555677!+! 9%9! %,!'!'E 9!FG4GG4!9%)$'0!`4GG6 "X*) ! ! F %'!$$9 ! [*3]                      

       

      !" #$%& "  

  '"() *               +$,             -. '"() -       /01234567427069:;<=>392?63/7096@2?/4AB73C       D  * E           -  F         '"()  D   D          :;<=>3067A/?   

 D  "    F G  *     F   '"()     3HBI7 B7 J64A4AB769>3 KA??C '"()     

 D              -    D                 [*4]                   !"#$         %  &  '    ()     * +'  ,   -./0.123        % &      (  )    ' %          &  (% -4504627 )         -/1.0112 8 ( )     ( 90   % &  ( /              7 )    9 % %   '                  7 )   % '%'       +   !"#$ ( 9         7   :          %(;<>?@A!BCD?A"E!#$BF$ !A$G @@ H$I  KL "A@A"M<E!N !"#$F <!$@F !FBBCACHA$HCB"AH!MC$ %  0  % &    [*5]                                                                                                                         !"$%&'()*+"),$"-+./012%+%23)4+/+5($"0')6+)6+$7$))4+                         8 9      

                    

                           :                                       8     8  8 8                          ;<=;;   >?@           :         ?@        =               =   A B  9   9  $"%C0",6'(20"(03D$EE42,4%+)+/*2"+%)4$))4+F+)2)20"+/2(G/+(.0"(2-6+30/)4+             HA  B    )4$)IJ)4+E$)+/'($K+,4$/K+(E+/+2"62"+E2)4L!MN5(/'6+(     O        P            A B       )4+F+)2)20"+/5(,6$2*+%          A   [*6]              !"#$%&$'  ()*

+   ,-./01235.06367/89:;<  **  = >:?< @* ==>:A<  B**

=  *=  C$$D&$EF&GFHGIJ$%I%ID$KKELMNO?M?AMAP:Q;RRM< : < STGE&E  V*   *=   *==@*  (      = V  **   =  Q**   *  ==*     **   

* *W!TX$K%IY$TTGARZ[O?M\?ZPRPO) ;P;;?M]^??NZ:;RZP<( * @*  ./_6_`.5_7a7_b9/7_60.,/5,c.,/6/-de`7ff7g_e/6_1_7a.b.,g5hC i$%I#!&Kj$k?ZAOA?AZ?\P:QAl)m?P;R<>E$$TE! mnop[O)>moqRQ)  rTIstTIu&%I%I#H!EAAMOA;??;;??\:QAl)m?P?;< [*7]                                              !"#$%'( (##()"'*()+,-#$*"+.(++$.'"(+)"'/0$'"'"(+$,1* 2     3       45671*     8  3       9 9     :; <=>? @ACDEFGHIJKALAMNOOGDPOQMADRPJEDSEJEDTEPUKLVF 0$'"'"(+$,1* ",*'!,W-X$+'"*'/!''/$Y$!,"+WZ ".$,  9   9          [\,$*-X\'"(+]9         ^SKPHK_PUE`JQabaTEQEFc dddedf; ghdiii?   j = h        ;  ?       9      3 h     '/!'[)/$+'/$"* (-+%'(k$)"'/"+!..$\'!k#$*'!+%!,%*( !..-,!.lm!no$,l *',(+W\,$*-X\'"(+"*.,$!'$%1"+ !o(,( '/$!..-,!.l 9 ]3  TEQEFp   9     IDKHP MPOKE9  [       ]qU   9       9       ^    9 TEQEF  9  [*8]          ! "            #$ %     #         # &  #  '%(!)*+,  $  # &   -       ./.123456778198:;<=>?@86./192A358B838@CD  E  &E   F "   '    # $ %    #  GHIJK HLLMHNOHPH IPQPRSTUJLOPOVLTHPWXHSLLOH K H  OQH YNJ OHK HZT[ OPVNNPRSTUJLOPOL  \83/3/218@>??8421.6@9]B813/?35   # ^   #   _           `#  abab"  $  %      cDd)      # ^   _       c  e       E         & # '%(!)*+,  $"   ^   cDd)        F"     [*9]                                         !   " #      $  $     %$#  &'()*+,-.-/0123-.56789:;<-=10> :-?;<13/@0=ABC&"('%(*%* D  E  FG       H   I    =-.J/K-;03/<3,-L;[email protected]=O<;MP/0?K10P-2;<<Q  "R G                            "  H      &"('%* S"('"  T-3/3/@0-.1.?;-=3,135,-O.@J/>->>@K;M-03=3@%*     ./0?U22/K-.1OO-1.->3@P-</-J-3,-.-V1=1.-W;/.-M-033,13,-5K@031K33,- O@</K-XNA %$H " Y*             I  H   I @25K@031K3/0?3,-O@</K-A         " T-3/3/@0-.N=1.?;M-0321/<=             "Z,-T-3/3/@0-.N=-J/>-0K-       "    %"&& &S*  G  [*10]                            !  "    #    $ %         #&  %   $    % '        !           %     $   (     %        #  $)    *$   #    $   #      "  +    ,"-  -$    . / (   %  0    )      !      !   1   

  %      23456749:;<9667=;73>?33@4<A49>BCD79E347=3F;47A3;2G4 %$!    H  !  ) +   #!         #       #   #  #   ##   %9I54A3;2G4 %$             # H  #   )       %     $. [*11]                            !              "          #   "    # $%&'()*+,-&..)0&%&12(%32.1&%45%6&'782-($&,.&' 1-+67&%2,')0&1-+67&%9.-($&,.&,+67&%(.1%5:('&'     ; "     !   <              =&12%)6&,)9.       ?  @     A)0&-23 B       C2,')02))0&D&2%(,EF44($&%  G ; ! H#IJ G ;  @ K"HIJ G ;  J    B       G ;   # B              #  L  >     #   B  4+%,(.0 A        MC       IG                   #  I>            [*12]                     !" #$%&'('!)!*+('  , -   ,   ./0#")(+!!1!1 !" #% 2,3 45656  -     7839: :;    ; <     =)!>+?)+@0!". < <A <   3 45656B.C<D <8A <  EF <G<  8     9  9 < <, . < < ; A <   <   F < <    < A <      H 56I 2 . < < ; A <  <<   <  2  <   , 9 < J< K  9 <    LK   ;    <      5   6 5  K  6J     < K  ;K  , !)'+0!)+)!1!1!+"M(+0!#!1)0>NH 8,;  K  -  #0#"!)=@>0)+O=)!"PQRS? <K LK T < K    - ,   ,K   , - , K    G -      ;< ,<        . <  <A <   ;   ;I K          <   <       [*13]                       !"#$$%!&'( )* + ,  ,- ,  .( " / *! ) !"01/2*!&'%*0')%*%((     ,             , 3 - ,  4    5           4    3  3     3          3 678 7  9:9;<=>   ? 6    @     , 3  8 ,       , ,@  A             ?BB  ,, BB     CD !1&'E0'*1!F 7   +G::+HIH+ G::    ;    5  , <  8 ,      ;9<       3     = ,    = ,  3   3           ,      3 3  8 , J              ,    ,        7  9:9;<         ,  A                     678    *K!&'K !'!L%' 0*1 % ))M!1 (N2*  ,3  [*14]              !"" #$%&'   ()     *  * +  , -."/012"% 346789:4;8<<=>4?@A>4BC4:D>??>BEF:8G78B;HIJKMNOPQROSSTUSOVWX Y.2Z2Z[\.]   ^   *        _ ( _((** (  ^ ^((^_ ` ) + ^ (( ()&,  a&bc  &bc_d(  d ^(  ((_ (( 2[ e. ].\f.].f g[\2h/0 [] ij1]2.]/0 1\f 2h12 hZkh eZ//l 2h[l. 2h12 .mn..f oo ".]n.\2 _  )   ^ c ((  ^  )& p.n2Z[\$qr\s.l2Zk12Zs.Y][n.fj].l %tZkhuZ//Y[/Zn0qql212.lv !\01nn[j\2whZnhZ\fZn12.l1lZ\k/.eZ//Z\kn0n/. n[\ljg"2Z[\2h12.mn..floo".]n.\2[x2h."].sZ[jl 0.1]y l1s.]1k.lh1//e.1j2[g12Zn1//0Z\s.l2Zk12.fe02h. z."1]2g.\2 wZ2h[j2nh1]k.2[2h.{jl2[g.]!ffZ2Z[\1//0| 1\01nn[j\2whZnhZ\fZn12.l1lZ\k/.eZ//Z\kn0n/. n[\ljg"2Z[\2h12.mn..fl2h."].sZ[jl0.1]y l1s.]1k.e0 g[].2h1\1}o".]n.\21s.]1k.|lh1//e.Z\s.l2Zk12.fe0 2h.z."1]2g.\2|122h.{jl2[g.]y l].ij.l2|wZ2h[j2nh1]k. 2[2h.{jl2[g.]~h.Z\s.l2Zk12[]wZ//f.2.]gZ\.Zx2h. g.2.]h1le..\n[]].n2/0].1f1\f122.g"22[f.2.]gZ\. wh.2h.]2h.].Zln[\2Z\jZ\k].kZl2]12Z[\|whZnhg10 Z\fZn12./.11k.[\2h.{jl2[g.]y l"][".]20t[w.s.]|Z2 Zl\[22h.].l"[\lZeZ/Z20[x2h.Z\s.l2Zk12[]2[nh.n1\0 Z\2.]\1/[].m2.]\1/"/jgeZ\ke./[\kZ\k2[2h.{jl2[g.] Y.2Z2Z[\.]1]kj.l2h12e.n1jl.fj."][n.ll].ijZ].l\[2Zn.1\f1\[""[]2j\Z20   _ (  ()* *d( & %qf."]Zs.f [*15]                       

  !"!# %&"'()           * +  ,, ./12345367.89:3;5<9 =>?@=A?BCD#EFG" H  IFFJH#KLMNG#O#P" (QFO#RHQI )#"OS "R#O"T#"R"HJ"UJ#"    V    W ,,XYZ    * Z * ,,   XYZ       )#"OS UHJJ[XYZ    XYZ          

"OTIE#(!\Q]I # Q(^_`aS  \"HJIO# [O"!G#O!G"(!G#b#"OH(Tc\\H]#OS "JJ#T#K\"HJIO# MX  V   *        

      *     Y   

     deeghijkllY lm n      * 

         o       p  q *   r    deestkkehtuvwexyjvshze{|x}~€~‚ƒ„…†‡~„‚ˆ‰Š‹vŒŽmY, r,,    *        p         XYZ  ***  V  ‘     ’#!H!HQ(#OS  *         

       * V      [*16]      !"#$%& '  %(&  ) ')) *  ( ) )+, ' -  ./0 12') .( 3  44''),* 5)3*6767 8 99 :7;<=,+/ >?> , @  ) A& . B>C  DEFGH$FIJK 4) ' ',@  ) + )'&99 .A&)4&*  ) 9&'& ) ,99 4 & ' L) '  (,$FHGGME ,)+++)*) ,'/0 12)++, * ) (;*9.* 9  , , *  (,  ( 8 99 N6<O))3/,,P (Q++ 4 +)&  +3))+@  ) /'&4,+  ()& & '&99).4)*9  '&'   3  4 =,+  ('.,P (Q++ 4/,+)/4)4 GKG$FHIR   =,@  ) +)0 )+L )  ',+)STUVTSW  1 5=QXY5Z  =% 0ZL[/\\ /LQ5L]%   LQ@ZY1-]%5Z1PY2=QLQ]51Y^ Q-%YLQ%2 52=Q 5_@ %=_ 5Q=%Y@%Y1Y5=Y2`_LQ]51Y^   [*17]                             

Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw