UNITED STATES
v.
MONTANA LUMBER AND MANUFACTURING COMPANY

U.S. | 1905-02-20
No. 125
Me. Justice Brewer concurs in the result.
196 U.S. 573 Supreme Court of the United States (1905) Positive Treatment
Also reported at: 49 L. Ed. 604 · 25 S. Ct. 367 · 1905 U.S. LEXIS 925 · SCDB 1904-193
Cited by 8 cases

AI-generated. These summaries, headnotes, and key points are machine-generated and may contain errors or omissions. Always verify against the full opinion text below. Not legal advice.

Synopsis

The United States brought suit to recover the value of timber that Montana Lumber and Manufacturing Company cut and removed from unsurveyed land that had been granted to the Northern Pacific Railroad Company by the 1864 Act. The Supreme Court held that until the Government completed its survey to identify which sections of land were granted to the railroad, the United States retained sufficient property interest in the timber to maintain an action for its recovery, and therefore reversed the trial court's judgment for the defendants.

© FLexlaw, Inc. — AI-generated enrichments are proprietary. All rights reserved.

Opinion of the Court
Me. Justice McKenna,

Mr. Justice McKenna,

after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.

In the view we take of the case the answer to the second question becomes unnecessary. The answer to the first and third depends upon thé effect of the grant to the Northern Pacific Railroad .Company by the', act of July 2, 1864. The third section of that act contains the usual granting words: "That there be, and hereby is, granted to the 'Northern Pacific Railroad Company,’ its successors and assigns,” every alternate section of public land, not mineral, designated by odd numbers, on each side of the line of the railroad when definitely fixed.

It has been decided many times that such grants are m, prossenti, and take effect upon the sections of the land when the road is definitely located, by relation as to the date of the grant. But the survey of the land is reserved to the Government (section 6); in other words, the identification of 'the sections — whether odd or eveh — is "reserved to the Government; and by the act of July 15, 1870, making appropriations for the sundry civil expenses of the Government for the .year ending June 30, 1871, it was provided, in regard to the grant to the Northern Pacific Railroad Company, that the cost of surveying must be paid by the company, and no conveyance should be made of the lands until such cost be paid. On account of that provision it .was held in Northern Pacific Railroad Company v. Traill County, 115 U. S. 600, that the land of a railroad company was not subject to taxation. It was said, "to secure the payment of those expenses,.-it (the Government) decided to retain the legal title in its own hands until they were paid.” See also New Orleans Pacific Railway Co. v. United States, 124 U. S.

124. The equitable title becomes a legal title only upon the identification of the granted sections. Deseret Salt Co. v. Tarpey, 142 U. S.

241. As expressed in Leavenworth &c. Railroad Co. v. United States, 92 U. S. 733, 741, "They” (the words "there be and is hereby granted”) "vest a present title, . . . though a survey o'f the lands and a location of the road are necessary to give precision to it, and attach it to any particular.tract.” The right of survey is in the United States. It was error, therefore, in the trial court to admit the survey made by Ashley. It was also error to instruct the jury to return a verdict for the defendants. • Until the identification of the even and odd-numbered sections the United Slates retained a special property, at least, in the timber growing in the township; and this was sufficient to enable it to recover the value of the timber cut and removed by the defendants. A contrary conclusion would impair the Government’s right of survey and force' it into controversies over surveys made by the railroad or its grantees." It. would enable the railroad, company or its grantees to despoil the lands of their timber and leave them denuded, and, may be worthless, to the Government. Indeed it woúld reverse the statutory grant of powers and transfer the location of the sections frpm the Government to the railroad-company. The extent - and' the effect of the power of the Government to make its own surveys is expressed and illustrated in the following cases: Maguire v. Tyler, 8 Wall. 650; Cragin v. Powell, 128 U. S. 691; United States v. McLaughlin, 127 U. S. 428; Blake v. Doherty, 5 Wheat. 358; Central Pacific Railroad Co. v. Nevada, 162 U. S. 512; United States v. Hanson, 16 Pet. 196; Les Bois v. Bramell, 4 How. 449; Mackey v. Dillon, 4 How. 421; Glenn v. United States, 13 How. 250; Smith v. United States, 10 Pet. 326.

There is nothing in Northern Pacific Railroad Company v. Hussey, 61 Fed. Rep. 231, which militates with these views; In that case relief was granted by injunction against a trespasser upon unsurveyed land at the suit of the railway company, it's contingent interest being. held sufficient for that purpose; The paramount control and property in the United States was not .in question.

We, therefore, answer the first and the third question' certified by the Circuit Court of Appeals in the affirmative-.

Mr. Justice Brewer concurs in the result.

Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus

Citator

Cited By

  • United States v. N. Pac. Ry. Co., 311 U.S. 317 (U.S. 1940)
    …S. 139; Southern Pacific R. Co. v. Bell, 183 U. S. 675. 256 U. S. 51, 66, 67. Atlantic & Pacific R. Co., 17 L. D. 313; Northern Pacific R. Co., 20 L. D. 187, 190. Hewitt v. Schultz, 180 U. S. 139, 152; United States v. Montana Lumber & Mfg. Co., 196 U. S. 573, 578; United States v. Morrison, 240 U. S. 192, 200; Cox v. Hart, 260 U. S. 427; Sawyer v. Gray, 205 F. 160, 163; Douglass v. Rhodes, 280 F. 230, 231; Northern Pacific Ry. Co. v. Lane, 46 App. D. C. 434. C. 561, § 4, 26 Stat. 1097. IV Kappler, 106…
  • Gleason v. White, 199 U.S. 54 (U.S. 1905)
    …t is-undoubtedly true that the official surveys of the public lands of the United States are controlling; Stoneroad v. Stoneroad, 158 U. S. 240; Russell v. Maxwell Land Grant Co., 158 U. S. 253; United States v. Montana Lumber and Manufacturing Co., 196 U. S. 573; Whitaker v. McBride, 197 U. S. 510. Here we have two conflicting official surveys and plats, and, by mistake of the Land Department, two patents have been issued, which, in a certain aspect of the surveys and plats, also conflict. It is one of thos…
  • Jones v. United States, 195 F.2d 707 (9th Cir. 1952)
    …ublic land, that “until surveyed no * * * sections could exist. Unsurveyed lands are not public lands”,2 was one adopted for the purpose of preserving “the power of the government to make its own surveys”, United States v. Montana Lumber & Mfg. Co., 196 U.S. 573, 25 S.Ct. 367, 368, 49 L.Ed. 604, and does not operate to limit the Government’s right, in the public interest, to withdraw lands, whether by reference to numbers of sections as yet unsurveyed, or otherwise. It was shown that “during the winter of…
    1 / 2

Authorities Cited (14 total)

View all 14 cited authorities →

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw