GIANATASIO

v.

KAPLAN ET AL.

Citator

Cited By

• White v. Gates, 253 F.2d 868 (D.C. Cir. 1958)
  …veterans’ constitutional rights. Gianatasio v. Kaplan, 257 N.Y. 531, 178 N.E. 782. Without comment, the United States Supreme Court dismissed an appeal from the Court of Appeals “for the want of a substantial federal question.” Gianatasio v. Kaplan, 284 U.S. 595, 52 S.Ct. 203, 76 L.Ed. 512. If veterans’ preference legislation conflicted with the President’s constitutional prerogative, so would much of the Civil Service legislation that has been in force for many years. More than 70 years ago the Supreme C…
• Soto-Lopez v. NEW York City Civil Serv. Comm'n, 755 F.2d 266 (2d Cir. 1985)
  …, ch. 133, § 5, 1982 N.Y.Laws 499, 501. . The August court also relied on Gianatasio v. Kaplan, 142 Misc. 611, 255 N.Y.S. 102 (Sup.Ct.N. Y.County), aff’d mem., 257 N.Y. 531, 178 N.E. 782 (1931), dismissed for want of a substantial federal question, 284 U.S. 595, 52 S.Ct. 203, 76 L.Ed. 512 (1932), which had upheld the provisions under attack here, using, at least in part, a "right/privilege” analysis. The August court did, however, acknowledge that the right/privilege rationale of that decision had been sub…
• Fredrick v. The United States, 507 F.2d 1264 (Ct. Cl. 1974)
  …ivil Service, 330 Mass. 22, 110 N.E. 2d 840 (1953); Swantush v. Detroit, 257 Mich. 389, 241 N.W. 265 (1932); State ex rel. Kangas v. McDonald, 188 Minn. 157, 246 N.W. 900 (1933); Gianatasio v. Kaplan, 257 N.Y. 531, 178 N.E. 782 (1931), cert. denied, 284 U.S. 595, 52 S.Ct. 203, 76 L.Ed. 512 (1932); Commonwealth ex rel. Graham v. Schmid, 333 Pa. 568, 3 A. 2d 701 (1938) (statute constitutional in part); State ex rel. Raines v. Seattle, 134 Wash. 360, 235 P. 968 (1925). On the other hand, some cases have foun…

Authorities Cited

• Atkin v. Kansas, 191 U.S. 207 (U.S. 1903)
• Heim v. McCALL, 239 U.S. 175 (U.S. 1915)