ADVISORY OPINION TO GOVERNOR

Fla. | 1942-12-21
152 Fla. 119 Florida Supreme Court (1942) Caution
Also reported at: 10 So. 2d 926
Cited by 8 cases

AI-generated. These summaries, headnotes, and key points are machine-generated and may contain errors or omissions. Always verify against the full opinion text below. Not legal advice.


Holding

The Governor has the executive power to assign a county solicitor from another county to represent the State when the resident county solicitor is disqualified and no one can be appointed under statute.


Facts & Procedural History

A judge of the Criminal Court of Record of Palm Beach County requested the Governor's assistance because the County Solicitor was disqualified in four…

The full statement of facts, procedural history, and disposition for this case are member content.

Join FLexlaw to unlock all legal intelligence

© FLexlaw, Inc. — AI-generated enrichments are proprietary. All rights reserved.


Opinion of the Court

*120STATE OF FLORIDA EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT TALLAHASSEE

December 11, 1942

T Spessard L. Holland

Governor

Ralph Davis

Executive Secretary

To the Honorable the Chief Justice and Justices of the Supreme Court of the State of Florida

GENTLEMEN:

I am in receipt of the following communication from the Honorable John L. Moore, Judge of the Criminal Court of Record of Palm Beach County, Florida:

“There are pending in the Criminal Court of Record of Palm Beach County, Florida, four cases, namely: State v. C. O. (Pete) Pierce and Benjamin F. Haley, charged with wrongful combination against workmen — case number 6940; State of Florida v. C. O. Pierce, Assault with Intent to Commit Murder; case no. 6920; State of Florida v. Benjamin F. Haley and Jack Holt, Assault & Battery case no. 6868, and State of Florida v. C. O. (Pete) Pierce, Possessing a Pistol without a License, no. 6863. In all of which cases the County Solicitor, W. E. Roebuck, has filed his written motion for an order of disqualification, which motion in each case has been granted by the Court.

“Section 32.17 Florida Statutes, 1941, gives the judge of the Criminal Court of Record ‘full authority to appoint a County Solicitor from among the members of the bar with the consent of such member so appointed’—

“The same numbered section of the statute fixes the compensation of such appointee as the same as received by the regular County Solicitor and to be paid by the County Solicitor.

“I have consulted several members of the bar that I felt were competent to prosecute these cases, with a view to appointing them with their consent as provided in the above *121named statute. These cases have received so much publicity and the compensation so small that the attorneys I have consulted do not wish to become involved therein. I feel that all will have the same answer in view of the work that they will entail.

“I, therefore, request that you assign some County Solicitor from another Criminal Court of Record, to represent the State in the above named causes, or that you may take any other steps that you may deem advisable to the end that the State may be properly represented.”

There appear to be no provisions of law specifically authorizing the assignment of a County Solicitor, the name usually ascribed to the prosecuting officer of Criminal Courts of Record, to a Criminal Court of Record in other counties in cases where the resident County Solicitor is disqualified, as may be done in the case of the disqualification of a State Attorney.

Availing myself of the privilege conferred by Section 13 of Article IV of the Constitution, I have the honor to request your written opinion as to whether or not, under the circumstances set forth in the foregoing letter from Judge Moore, presenting, as I am satisfied it does, a situation in which the State of Florida will be without official representation in the disposition of said cases for lack of some person qualified to act as such representative, I have the power and authority, under Section 6 of Article IV, or any other provision of the Constitution, to assign the County Solicitor of some other Criminal Court of Record in this State or some State Attorney, to represent the State of Florida in the disposition of said cases.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Spessard L. Holland

SPESSARD L. HOLLAND

Governor

*122SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA

Armstead Brown, Chief Justice

TALLAHASSEE

December 17, 1942

Division A — Justices

James B. Whitfield

Rivers Buford

Alto Adams

Guyte P. McCord, Clerk

Division B — Justices

Glenn Terrell

Roy H. Chapman

Elwyn Thomas

R. S. Williams, Marshal

Honorable Spessard L. Holland

Governor of Florida

Tallahassee, Florida

Dear Sir:

Your request under Section 13, Article IV of the Constitution, is in effect for an opinion as to whether or not, under the circumtsances stated, you have the executive power and authority, under Section 6 of Article IV or any other provision of the Constitution, to assign the county solicitor of some other criminal court of record in this State or some state attorney, to represent the State of Florida in the prosecution of the cases mentioned. Since, as indicated in your letter, the circumstances present a situation in which the State of Florida will be without official representation in the disposition of stated criminal cases for lack of some person qualified to act as such representative, unless executive action is authorized by law, it is our opinion that under the provisions of Section 6, Article IV of the Florida Constitution that “the Governor shall take care that the Laws be faithfully executed,” you have the power to assign the county solicitor of the criminal court of record of any other county to discharge the duties of the County Solicitor of the Criminal Court of Record for Palm Beach County, by analogy to the provisions of Section 27.14 of the Florida Statutes 1941 relating to the assignment of state attorneys of the circuit court.

/s/ ARMSTEAD BROWN /s/ RIVERS BUFORD

Chief Justice /s/ R. H. CHAPMAN

/s/ J. B. WHITFIELD /s/ ALTO ADAMS

/s/ GLENN TERRELL

Justices of the Supreme Court.


Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus


Citator

Cited By

  • …nt state attorney, the trial judge were unable to select an acting state attorney from the members of the Bar, this constitutional provision is sufficient to authorize the assignment of a state attorney by the Governor. Advisory Opinion to Governor, 152 Fla. 119, 10 So. 2d 926 (1942). We hold that if for any good and sufficient reason the Governor thinks that the ends of justice would best be served, he may assign any state attorney of the State to the discharge of the duties of state attorney in any inves…
  • Kirk v. Baker, 224 So. 2d 311 (Fla. 1969)
    …ecuted by the State Attorney or any of his regular and duly appointed Assistants. “The Court therefore on its own motion and under the authority of Chapter 32.17 Florida Statutes [F.S.A.], and having considered the advisory opinion to the Governor, 10 So. 2d 926. “ORDERS that RICHARD E. GER-STEIN, State Attorney in and for the 11th Judicial Circuit of Florida, and his duly appointed Assistant State Attorneys, investigators and other persons regularly employed by the Office of the State Attorney in and for…
  • …bit of authority of the Chief Executive when exercised within the hounds of the statute. See Kirk v. Baker, 224 So. 2d 311 (Fla.1969).” (254 So. 2d at page 204; emphasis added) [*820] Respondents seek to rely upon Advisory Opinion to Governor, 1942, 152 Fla. 119, 10 So. 2d 926. There, the Supreme Court approved the assignment of a County Solicitor from outside the county to which he was assigned in the absence of legislative treatment of the particular circumstances there involved. Clearly, under such circu…

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw