CHAPPELLE
v.
GREATER BATON ROUGE AIRPORT DISTRICT ET AL.

U.S. | 1977-05-16
No. 76-352
431 U.S. 159 Supreme Court of the United States (1977) Positive Treatment
Also reported at: 52 L. Ed. 2d 223 · 97 S. Ct. 2162 · SCDB 1976-103 · 1977 U.S. LEXIS 85
Cited by 3 cases
Per_curiam
Per Curiam.

Per Curiam.

The judgment is reversed. Turner v. Fouche, 396 U. S. 346, 361-364 (1970).

Dissent
Mr. Justice Rehnquist,

Mr. Justice Rehnquist,

dissenting.

Appellant, E. C. Chappelle, Jr., wished to serve, upon appointment, as a commissioner on the Greater Baton Rouge Airport Commission. He, however, was deemed not qualified since, at the time of his appointment, he owned no “property assessed in East Baton Rouge Parish,” as required by Louisiana Act 151 of 1969. The sole requirement is that he own property, whether real or personal; that is assessed in that parish. We sit to judge the constitutionality, not the wisdom, of this restriction. I am unable to agree that the Constitution, or prior cases from this Court, require today’s declaration of unconstitutionality.

This Court has regularly sustained the imposition of city or county residency requirements on municipal employees. McCarthy v. Philadelphia Civil Serv. Comm’n, 424 U. S. 645 (1976); Detroit Police Officers Assn. v. Detroit, 405 U. S. 950 (1972); see also Bute v. Quinn, 535 F. 2d 1285 (CA7), cert. denied, 429 U. S. 1027 (1976). It is dubious at best whether the requirement that a public officeholder own any assessable property within a parish is any more burdensome, or any less rational, than a requirement that he and his family live in that parish.

This Court has also sustained durational residency requirements of five and seven years for candidates for the office of state governor and senator, Kanapaux v. Ellisor, 419 U. S. 891 (1974); Sununu v. Stark, 420 U. S. 958 (1975). If a State can impose a five-year residency requirement on its candidates for its highest political office, it should be able to impose a minimal locational property requirement on persons seeking office in this airport district.

The Louisiana Court of Appeal concluded:

“In enacting Act 151 of 1969, the legislature sought to insure that the members of the commission would have a substantial interest in performing their duties effectively and conscientiously. The legislature could have concluded reasonably that property owners of East Baton Rouge Parish would have that interest.” App. 22-23.

Surely it was as reasonable to conclude so in this case as it is in situations involving residency, or durational residency, requirements. Since I believe today’s opinion is inconsistent with these cases, and since, in light of these later cases, I would not extend Turner v. Fouche, 396 U. S. 346, 361-364 (1970), I respectfully dissent.

Cases With Similar Vibessemantic neighbors from the corpus

Citator

Cited By

  • Int'l Bus. Machs. Corp. v. The United States, 343 F.2d 914 (Ct. Cl. 1965)
    …States, 142 F. Supp. 907, 908-909, 135 Ct.Cl. 650, 653-654 (1956); Wolinsky v. United States, 271 F. 2d 865, 868 (C.A. 3,1959); Weller v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 270 F. 2d 294, 299 (C.A. 3,1959), cert. denied, 364 U.S. 908, 81 S.Ct. .269, 52 L.Ed.2d 223 (1960) ; Goodstein v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 267 F. 2d 127, 132 (C.A. 1, 1959); City Loan & Savings Co. v. United States, 177 F.Supp. 843, 851 (N.D.Ohio, 1959), aff’d, 287 F. 2d 612, 616 (C.A. 6, 1961). Equality of treatment is so domin…
  • Quinn v. Millsap, 491 U.S. 95 (U.S. 1989)
    …t to the board [of freeholders] was actually limited to those who were ascertained to be owners of real property.” Ibid. Relying on this Court’s decisions in Turner v. Fouche, 396 U. S. 346 (1970), and Chappelle v. Greater Baton Rouge Airport Dist., 431 U. S. 159 (1977), appellants asserted that the requirement that members of the board own real property — whether contained within § 30 itself or resulting from a misinterpretation of that provision — is not rationally related to any legitimate state purpose.…
    1 / 2

Authorities Cited

Full citator, related cases, and AI research tools

Open in FLexlaw